Want quality AG?
Find out how to help by clicking the image above!



Instagram YouTube

My writing/fandom blog!
I Ship These Characters!
Button Swap!

Take my button, and let me know you did! Please make sure your buttons are no more than 150 px wide, and I will post them here. Copy this code to your website or blog:

Indecisive Me!

Girls- I am going absolutely insane right now! I am a VERY indecisive person, so when it comes down to which doll I wanna ask for, for Christmas- I just about die! ๐Ÿ˜›

I am having SO many problems trying to decide between Isabelle or MAG #61 (who will be named Jenna)!



I want both of them SO badly! I’m pretty sure I want MAG#61 more, but here’s my problem:

Although I want #61 more, I’m afraid that if I get her for Christmas, I’m going to regret not getting Isabelle since she won’t be available anymore. And I also really want Isabelle, so I’m just like- URGH!
AND if I get Isabelle for Christmas will I be disappointed I didn’t get #61 first even though I can buy her on my birthday just 2 months later?

Advice, opinions, and HELP would be greatly appreciated right now! ๐Ÿ˜€


34 Responses to Indecisive Me!

  • I highly suggest getting #61 for Christmas, and getting the new GOTY for your birthday. (btw when is ur Q&A going be and pleeeeaaaasse do a what would you name her soon plus Tell Us Tuesday ๐Ÿ™‚

  • Well it isn’t up to me, but if I were you an I could get a doll for my birthday, I’d probably get Isabelle for Christmas just because she will be leaving soon.

    My gosh, I’m having a similar problem.

  • Maybe you shouldn’t get a doll right now. You wouldn’t want to regret getting one doll and/or not getting the other. Do you really need to ask for a doll for Christmas? It would seem to me that the more time passes without a new doll, you could build your relationships with your old ones. But it’s your decision! ๐Ÿ™‚


  • My thought is Isabelle will be gone by December, but Jenna will be there for a couple more years… I would go for Isabelle and Jenna for your birthday, that way yo can get both. Just think with Saamantha, They retired her before you could get her, but Isabelle wouldn’t be brought back.
    Hope I helped!

  • see if you can put one or both on layaway until your birthday. see how many months ahead of your birthday you can start a layaway.

  • I would get Isabelle for Christmas, then #61 for your birthday. Isabelle would already be retired by the time your birthday comes, and you don’t know if you’ll be able to get a good deal on eBay or something. ๐Ÿ˜‰

  • I would get Isabelle if you really want her. Personal shoppers have told me how high she sells and how she is predicted to sell on the secondary market very well. I would just wait 2 months to get #61. Imagine how frustrating it would be to really regret not getting Isabellle later on. In the worst case scenario, you could always wait 2 months to get #61.

  • The decision is totally yours, but I would recommend Isabelle both because I have her and because knowing which dolls you have, she might be a little more unique. Isabelle is really pretty but Jenna is too!

  • Hmm. I’d personally get Isabelle, since when the Christmas rush hits, she’s going to sell out fast. (taking from my experiences with Molly in Christmas 2013) #61 will still be there for your B-day, so, yeah. That’s just my opinion, but I highly suggest getting Isabelle for Christmas. ๐Ÿ˜‰ Good luck!

  • If you don’t get Isabelle now, she’ll be gone. Get her first , and if and when you get another doll, get #61.

  • If you really want Isabelle, then why not wait until your birthday for the My AG doll? It isn’t really that far after Christmas. And think about how much you like Isabelle. If she was a My AG doll, would you like her as much? Do you like her for what she looks like as a doll, or do you partly like her because of her collection and her story? Also, since you don’t really have that many blonde dolls, maybe that is a plus in her favor. Hope this is helps even a little! ๐Ÿ™‚
    ~Christian Homeschooler

  • If Isabelle is one that you REALLY want, I would get her. You can always get #61 for your birthday !! ๐Ÿ˜‰
    And if you like the new GOTY when she comes out, you can buy her instead of #61. (If you want to)
    Good luck deciding!

  • I have both Isabelle and #61, and I love them both dearly! They’re both so unique in their own way. But, a few months ago, I regretted not getting a few GOTY’s in their year, and my mom just asked me why I didn’t just get them when they were available. I said I had my eyes on other dolls. She told me you might as well just get them in their year or you will regret it. She was right, so when we went up to the AGP, I brought Isabelle home with me, even though I planned to get an MAG. And especially because your birthday is only two months later, I think It’d be better to get Isabelle first ๐Ÿ™‚
    This is just my opinion however, if you really want #61 that badly, and feel like the two months would be torture, then you could totally get her, and then maybe find Isabelle on Ebay, or something like that ๐Ÿ™‚

  • I would get Isabelle because she won’t be available anymore after the first of the year. MAG #61 is the one that just came out so you will have more time to get her.

  • Although both these dolls are beautiful (and I have Isabelle!) I would recommend Isabelle, as she’s only here for 1 year! The stock photos do not do her justice! Hope this helps!

  • I think you should ask for Isabelle for Christmas and get MAG#61 for your birthday. Because Izzy would probably be like double $120 later because she would be retired, and MAG#61 would stay at her normal price until, who knows when? That’s my advice.
    P.S. I have Isabelle and she is a great doll, I totally recommend her! ๐Ÿ™‚

  • You should get Izzy she will be retired soon and you could get 61 later also 61 is a TON like Saige and Felicity.

  • I’m not the biggest fan of Isabelle, she just hasn’t really clicked on me. So I would get #61 for Christmas for me. (I LOVE #61!!! SOOOOO CUTE!!!) HOWEVER, since you like them both so much, I would ask for Isabelle. She will only be here a little while longer. ๐Ÿ˜‰

    ~Lydia~ <3

  • Even though I like # 61 better than Isabelle, I would get Isabelle since she is going to retire by the end of the year. #61 just came out, so I don’t think she will be retiring any time soon. I totally understand your problem. I think most ag collectors go through this all the time :D. I guess you could get Isabelle of of ebay, but she will be really expensive.


  • I don’t have either doll, so I can’t tell you stuff like “Isabelle’s hair highlights are lots of fun” or “#61 is super photogenic” (I have no idea) but I think you should get Isabelle and you will only have to go 2 months without Jenna, who is probably always gonna be there when you are ready!

  • Isabelle. she’ll be gone after december. Plus she’s so cute!
    And the GOTY kinda looks a lot like saige, no offense. ๐Ÿ™‚

  • Personally, I think Isabelle. She is the prettiest girl of the year yet. She comes with an awesome outfit and book, not to mention her highlights. I am possibly going to get her… you can go to my blog bluebonnetsandbees.blogspot.com to vote on what I should get. the discion is totally up to you.

  • Buy Isabelle. Because if you don’t buy her soon she’ll archive. ๐Ÿ™‚



  • I had the same problem! I was choosing between Isabelle and #55! I am going to get #55 for my B-day (Oct. 18th) Hannah from Agdtime really helped me! She has Isabelle, BTW. I think you should get #61 if you want to do her hair or Isabelle if you don’t really care about doing her hair. I really hope this helps!


  • I think you should buy Isabelle. She’s only available for one year, and MYAG #61 just came out, so she will be there for at least 2 years, so you could buy her later.
    Follow your heart!


  • Omg!!! The above comment is from me, Bella! Just to let you know, I will now address my comments by BellaAGFan;)
    Hope that helped you out.

  • In my opinion get Jenna, because trust me next year you (If you get Isabelle) will want to get a MAG Doll, because you just got a GOTY Doll the year before. But then next year’s doll will be prettier/better, and you’ll want her, so just save yourself and GET JENNA! ๐Ÿ™‚

  • (Ok, so firstly, I’ve been reading your blog for awhile but haven;t commented before…Dumb me:P)

    I think you should get Isabelle since she’ll be gone at the end of the year.:) You’ll have lots of time to get #61 after that:)

  • Bella:
    No problem! Glad to help you out a bit ;]


  • p.s. I even changed my account by accident ;]


  • Although I have seen a vast majority of people saying the same thing I’m going to say, I am still going to say it. I (personally) would get Isabelle first, then wait two months for Jenna. It works out nicely with the timing, so that you could get both– while if you got Jenna first, you might not end up with both dolls. Jenna should still be available after Christmas, but we know that AG isn’t going to sell Isabelle after Christmas. I hope that you love whichever doll you choose.
    XOXO Ginger Spice

  • I would say get Isabelle now while you still can, then get Jenna. I regret not getting Saige when I could have because I could still get the one I got now. Jenna just came out, so she’ll be here a while.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

My Etsy Shop

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.